First Off - NYX Liquid Black Liner

I was on the hunt for a specific NYX eyeliner, and could not find it. So I bought this one instead. 

I am torn about this. It like it but I don't. The brush is very thin and I find it hard to apply in the thickness that I want, on both eyes. Thus far I have ended up with it far thicker than I wanted. And I have made it work.

The other thing that makes me not love it is the fact that it is not a matte formula. I was not aware that I had a preference for my eyeliner finish. But this has a shine to it. And when I am out and about in my day, and glance in a mirror to double check that my makeup has not melted, the finish often makes me thing that I am missing eyeliner on a spot on my eye. This leads to me quickly brushing on another coat of it, and then building it up to the point where it is drying an annoying.

Verdict: Other than the two concerns I listed, I like this product. It wears all day and isn't uncomfortable. It's not my favourite eyeliner, but I have tried worse ones.